Best-rated Hotels in Sag Harbor for an Unforgettable Stay

Book your perfect accommodation with our detailed descriptions, travelers’ reviews, and handpicked hotel collections.

Check-in date:
Check-out date:
0 Adults

Adults

0 Children

Children

Apply

Why Book With Us?

Choose from exclusive hotel collections.

We offer thousands of Sag Harbor hotels and accommodations from some of the world's most renowned hotel chains as well as unique gems in the region that you won’t find anywhere else.

Enjoy a seamless booking experience.

After choosing your accommodation, take a minute to complete our quick reservation form and get instant confirmation by email.

Get flexible travel options.

We provide the most flexible cancellation options. Get your deposit back in case of a change of plans and other unforeseen circumstances.

Find a hotel

Hotels by class
2 stars 1
Unrated 14
Thematic Hotels
Luxury accommodations 6
Resorts 4
Beach hotels 3
Private Villas 3
Boutique hotels 2
Hotels with indoor pool 2
Jacuzzi 1
Spa hotels 1
Beachfront hotels 1
Luxury hotels 1
Golf hotels 1
Exceptional Design hotels 1
Business hotels 1
Small Luxury Hotels 1

Hotels by location

Nearby
Custom House 11
Off the Rocker Sag Harbor 9
Bay Street Theatre Sag Harbor 8
Landmarks
Museum
Popular attractions

Welcome To Sag Harbor

Discover the charm of Sag Harbor, nestled on the beautiful East End of Long Island, NY. Immerse yourself in its rich history, explore the quaint shops and galleries, and indulge in delicious seafood overlooking the picturesque harbor. Join us in experiencing the magic of Sag Harbor's vibrant community and breathtaking surroundings. Plan your visit today and embark on an unforgettable journey!

What Our Users Say About Popular Sag Harbor Hotels

9.8

Exceptional

us Phil 15 October 2022
The hotel's location was ideal and fab very close to all metro lines. Our room was new-fashioned and provided with an amazing view and extra Duvet, for instance as expected.
Read more +
Show Less -
9.8

Exceptional

us Glenn 09 March 2023
A flat-screen TV with cable channels, climate control and an individual safe available in the signature king suite. The bed was exceptionally comfortable and the breakfast was marvellous and nice.
Read more +
Show Less -
9.8

Exceptional

us Randall 14 December 2022
Our room was a king suite with all the amenities we needed, including climate control, pay TV, and coffee/tea making equipment. The location of this venue was fantastic, with a beautiful water fountain nearby and easy accessibility. we had a wonderful experience here and would highly recommend it.
Read more +
Show Less -
9.8

Exceptional

us Roger 14 January 2023
The hotel was stylish in general, had knowledgeable staff on the early morning shift. The location was easy, just 10 min walk from R Lounge. It was located in a really cool area. I appreciated functional room complete with amazing shower and 2 double beds and kettle. Everything was really good as expected, nonetheless the bathroom was leaking.
Read more +
Show Less -
9.8

Exceptional

us Kyle 24 February 2023
Wanted to explore New York City and this hotel was amazing base for doing it. The ideal and strategic location was a couple of blocks away from The Ride. There was a lovely restaurant just a short walk away from the venue. We had a perfectly pleasant time.
Read more +
Show Less -
9.8

Exceptional

us John 14 March 2023
Good for shopping. A brand-new and incredible room provided with queen beds and bathroom and skyline view. Central location, wonderful base for discovering New York City.
Read more +
Show Less -
9.8

Exceptional

us Paul 11 December 2022
We lovely spend 4 nights in New York City. This hotel had a central position on the main street.
Read more +
Show Less -
9.8

Exceptional

us Betty 14 September 2022
Great location near Palace Theatre! The area around here is super fun, with Times Square, restaurants, and the subway all within easy reach. It's a really convenient spot to be based out of. 🎉
Read more +
Show Less -
9.8

Exceptional

us Katherine 13 August 2022
We had a great time.
Read more +
Show Less -
9.8

Exceptional

us Bonnie 14 April 2023
Unbeatable spot near Broadway and Times Square and center. Also, very close to everything.
Read more +
Show Less -

Save Time on Trip Arrangements by Booking One of Our Hand-picked Hotels

Best 4-star Hotels
Quality 2-star Hotels
Experience the best value for money by checking out our selection of 4-star Sag Harbor hotels.
Baron'S Cove Hotel

31 W. Water Street, Sag Harbor, United States

Excellent
117 reviews

219 US$

min. price/night

Discover the hidden gems of Sag Harbor by booking one of its 2-star hotels.
Forever Bungalows Hotel

765 Rt. 114 - Egypt Lane Historic District, Sag Harbor, United States

Excellent
2 reviews

485 US$

min. price/night

Thank you for your feedback

Close